60 Legit Gift Ideas for Fans of the Show Supernatural

ⓘ The Elder Geek makes mad bank (receives a commission) if you buy something using a link on this page.

Supernatural (SPN) has amassed a very dedicated fanbase in its 15 years on the air – in fact, the fans being as loyal and as active in their fandom, as they are is often credited for the show’s longevity.

Wayward Sons and Daughters have even influenced the show with their ships and fanfic to an extent that doesn’t exist with many (if any) other shows.

So, What Do You Buy Fans of the show Supernatural?

If you’re looking for a gift for the die-hard SPN fan in your life, you want to make sure it’s perfect.

The 60 Best Gifts for Fans of Supernatural!


Supernatural Funko POP! Figures

It’s hard for a fan to resist Funko POP! Figures of their favorite characters and these SPN POP! Figures are no exception. Gift them their favorite character, ship or the whole gang, any fan would love to display these on their shelf or desk!

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Signed Pilot Script Reprint

Especially now that the show has ended this will be a super special gift for the Supernatural fan in your life. This Signed Pilot Scrip Reprint will be a cherished piece of memorabilia for them to remember their favorite show.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Fact: There’s actually an official Supernatural Day in Austin, Texas – June 23, 2018.

Supernatural Jensen and Jared Printed Pillowcase

If the Supernatural cast are known for anything it’s trolling their fans and making themselves meme-worthy, and this Supernatural Jensen and Jared Printed Pillowcase represents that perfectly. Gift the Jensen and Jared fan in your life this meme-worthy pillowcase to adorn their bed with.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Keep Calm and Carry On My Wayward Son Hoodie

Every fan can’t help but think Supernatural when they hear the first notes of this Kansas song. Remind them to Keep Calm and Carry On with this Hoodie.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Face Mask

Protect yourself from more than just demons, angels and all things supernatural with this Face Mask.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Vinyl Record Clock

A unique gift for the SPN fan this Supernatural Vinyl Record Clock will be a focal point for any fan’s home or office space.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Singer Auto Salvage Notepad

Keep track of all your fake FBI/CIA/Fishing and Wildlife numbers on your very own Singer Auto Salvage Notepad.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Carry on my Wayward Son Baby Keychain

While you may not be able to have your own Baby, you can pretend you do every time you grab your car keys with this Carry on my Wayward Son Baby Keychain.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Scoobynatural Pillow Cover

The crossover we didn’t know we needed – Scooby Doo and Supernatural. A combination of childhood nostalgia and their love of Supernatural is something they’re sure to want to show off with this Scoobynatural Pillow Cover.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Vinyl Sticker Pack

Plaster your love of SPN everywhere with the Supernatural Vinyl Sticker Pack. Laptops, water bottles, phone cases, you name it – showing off your dedication to your favorite show can be fun with stickers!

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

15 Years of Supernatural Fleece Throw Blanket

Commemorate the end of an era with the 15 Years of Supernatural Fleece Throw Blanket. A comfy throw for all the hours you’re definitely going to be spending rewatching the show from beginning to end.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

John Winchester Hardcover Ruled Journal

Keep a journal of your own life with tips and notes from John Winchester himself with the John Winchester Hardcover Ruled Journal. A great way for the Supernatural fan to start journaling.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Bobby Singer’s Guide to Hunting

For fans of the stubborn and loveable Bobby Singer his Guide To Hunting is like a look inside his mind – quite literally. Learn more about Bobby and hunting from his perspective with this book.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

John Winchester’s Journal

Your very own copy of John Winchester’s Journal! All the notes that the Brothers use on their cases in your hands. If you’re not quite ready to leave SPN behind, dive back in with this book.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Necklace 4 Pack

Whether it’s an anti-possession necklace for protection, or a replica amulet of Dean’s this Necklace 4 Pack give you all the iconic Supernatural necklaces and symbols to choose from. Keep them all or share with your other SPN fandom bffs!

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Anti-Possession Drinking Glass Set

Coming home after a tough case? Celebrating a win? These Anti-Possession Drinking Glasses are the perfect way to toast to all life’s little reasons to celebrate while protecting you from demon possession – win, win right?

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Scoobynatural Bifold Wallet

Add some personality to typically simple day-to-day accessory – your wallet. This Scoobynatural Bifold Wallet is a fun way to show your love of the show.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Lanyard

Whether you use it to keep track of your keys, your con pass, or display your FBI badge this Supernatural Lanyard is the perfect choice for any fan.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Convention Ticket

The ultimate gift for the Wayward Son or Daughter in your life. The Creation Entertainment Supernatural Convention is the most talked about in the fandom. It features appearances from many of the shows cast, karaoke night, panels and tons of other Supernatural-themed events. This is something that no fan will want to miss!

Buy it Nowfrom creation entertainment

Supernatural Fact: Supernatural is the longest running sci-fi series in the history of American broadcast TV!

Supernatural I’m Surrounded by Idjits Mug

For those days that you feel like Bobby and you want to let them know exactly how you feel (especially before your morning coffee) – The I’m Surrounded by Idjits Mug is a great gift.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

2021 Supernatural Collector’s Edition Calendar

This is more than your typical calendar the 2021 Supernatural Collector’s Edition Calendar comes complete with a special gift box and 2 8×10 posters for you to display all year ’round.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Seasons Box Sets

Now that the show is over there’s one thing ever SPN fan is going to want to do – rewatch their favorite show from the beginning. With streaming rights constantly bouncing around between services, Supernatural Seasons Box Sets are a surefire way to make sure they can always watch their favorite show whenever they want!

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural: The Official Coloring Book

Color along to your favorite show with the Supernatural Coloring Book. Add your artistic touch to all your favorite items, characters and scenes.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Winchester Brothers T-Shirt

Saving People, Hunting Things, The Family Business – the iconic slogan from the show on a cute tee! Every fan needs something celebrating the family business so why not gif them this tee?

Buy it Nowfrom hot topic

Driving Rules T-Shirt

If you tend to get frustrated when the passenger takes control of your radio this shirt is for you. The infamous line from Dean immortalized on this super cool tee featuring the one and only Baby.

Buy it Nowfrom hot topic

Supernatural Symbols PJ Pants

You’ll feel as safe as can be in these Supernatural Symbols PJ Pants. Anti-possession, Angel Banishing and more you’ll be out of harms way while you catch some Zzzs,

Buy it Nowfrom hot topic

Bitch & Jerk Salt Bottle BFF Necklace

For your SPN BFF these Bitch & Jerk Salt Bottle BFF Necklaces are the ideal way to show off your shared love of Supernatural and your friendship!

Buy it Nowfrom hot topic

Get in Loser Supernatural Socks

There’s nothing better than a fun pair of socks! These Get in Loser! No Show Socks are ready for adventure.

Buy it Nowfrom hot topic

Peace Out Charlie T-Shirt

What Supernatural post is complete without mentioning Charlie? The beloved character that was gone too soon – this Peace Out Charlie T-Shirt lets you celebrate one of your favorite characters, with the best goodbyes.

Buy it Nowfrom hot topic

Bitch & Jerk Crew Socks

You don’t need to choose favorites with these Bitch & Jerk Crew Socks. Celebrate your love of both the Winchester brothers with these fun socks.

Buy it Nowfrom hot topic

Wooden Supernatural Candle Lantern

The beautiful Wooden Supernatural Candle Lantern is a unique gift any fan would love. A great housewarming gift this lantern casts images such as baby, the brothers, sigils and more on your walls when you light a candle inside.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Carry on my Wayward Son Retro T-Shirt

This Carry on my Wayward Son Retro T-shirt would definitely be Dean approved. An easy to wear classic, retro tee featuring the Kansas song we’ve come to associate with the recaps and the beloved Baby every fan will appreciate having this tee in their wardrobe.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Custom Supernatural Sneakers

These Custom Supernatural Sneakers are a super special gift to give the SPN fan in your life. Customize them with images, names or logos that reflect the fangirl/fanboy in you’re life and you’re sure to impress them with this gift!

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Retro Castiel My People Skills Are Rusty T-Shirt

For fans of the loveable socially inept angel, Castiel. This Retro Castiel My People Skills Are Rusty T-Shirt is the perfect addition to their wardrobe.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Supernatural Lighter

If Supernatural has taught you anything, you always need a lighter, you know… demon bones, etc. This Supernatural Lighter is a great addition to your hunting toolkit.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Castiel Candle

Bring a bit of angel grace to your home with the Castiel Candle. A fresh forest scent that’ll be loved by all.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Supernatural Fact: Castiel’s outfit may look familiar – it’s based off the comic book character Constantine.

Chevy Impala from Supernatural Poster

Have a Supernatural fan in your life that loves cars? or maybe they just love Dean’s car? This Chevy Impala from Supernatural Poster is exactly the memorabilia that they’ll want in their home.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Supernatural-inspired Dean Winchester Oven Mitt

The many meme-worthy faces of Dean. What fan wouldn’t love laughing at this oven mitt every time they need to pull a dish from the oven?

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Supernatural Glyphs Engraved Wood Plaque

Decorate your home with this beautiful Supernatural Glyphs Engraved Wood Plaque. The SPN fan in your life will love adding this classic piece to their wall or shelf.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Dean Winchester Air Freshener

If you can’t have Dean’s car, bring a little Dean to your car with this Dean Winchester Air Freshener.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Jack Winchester Candle

The sweet little Nephilim that stole the hearts of the fandom in the later seasons. This cinnamon roll scented candle is the perfect candle for the SPN fan’s kitchen.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Winchester Hunting Academy Certificate

Make their love of SPN even more official. For all those aspiring hunters in your life award them their very own Winchester Hunting Academy Certificate!

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Personalized Supernatural Decanter and Whisky Glass Set

Celebrate or have a night cap like only the Winchesters could with the Personalized Supernatural Decanter and Whisky Glass Set. This beautiful set will make a truly thoughtful gift for the Supernatural (and whisky) fan in your life.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Sam Winchester Candle

A classic flannel scent can only mean one character – Sam. This candle will remind them of their favorite Winchester brother and is the perfect all-around scent for any home. The Sam Winchester Candle would make a thoughtful housewarming (or bunker-warming) gift.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Supernatural Leggings

There’s nothing better for fighting demons, working out or just your day-to-day convince store runs than the perfect pair of leggings. Protect yourself from possession and other supernatural entities with these Supernatural leggings.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Supernatural Impala Wood Coasters

These Supernatural Impala Wood Coasters are a step up from those cheap plastic ones we all seem to have but never remember buying. You’ll WANT to use these every chance you get. With a simple and beautiful engraved wood design featuring Baby and the boys’ beloved Kansas song these would make a great gift for the SPN fan in your life.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Retro Dean Winchester That Was Scary T-Shirt

One of the most loved episodes in Supernatural history – Yellow Fever, see’s Dean inflicted with an illness that makes him highly anxious and scared (yes, hilarity ensues). Always remember scaredy cat Dean with this Retro Dean Winchester That Was Scary T-Shirt.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Supernatural Fact: The cast are known to prank each other – just watch the bloopers! It’s well-known that if you’re a newcomer to the show you’re bound to get a warm welcome by way of SPN hazing.

Winchester Embroidered Crewneck

Prefer to be more subtle about your love of the Winchester’s? This Winchester Embroidered Crewneck is the wardrobe essential sweater everyone needs with a subtle nod to the Winchesters in the form of small embroidered script. It’ll be easy to work a tiny bit of your beloved show into your everyday outfits with this sweater.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Dean’s Cherry Pie Herbal Tea

While we all can’t get away with eating Pie as much as Dean seems to, that doesn’t mean we need to miss out. The Dean’s Cherry Pie Herbal Tea lets you have your cake (without eating it too!).

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Destiel Face Mask

Arguably the most popular ship in all of Supernatural – Dean and Castiel. A ship that definitely got played up in the show due to its fanbase (and fanfic). For the Destiel shipper this Introverted but Willing to Discuss Destiel Face Mask will be their new favorite way of staying safe in this new normal.

Buy it Nowfrom redbubble

Supernatural Christmas Ornament

Christmas ornaments often end up being representative of the things we love and important moments in our lives – so make sure you show your love of SPN with this Supernatural Christmas Ornament. This minimalist wood ornament will seamlessly fit with all your other decor while showing off your dedication to your fave TV show.

Buy it Nowfrom etsy

Supernatural CLUE

Solve your own cases with the Supernatural CLUE board game. Figure out what character has been possessed as is wrecking havoc on the town – you’ll love competing with friends to solve the crime and hunt down the possessed.

Buy it Nowfrom hot topic

Supernatural: Anime Series

Not every SPN fan knows that Supernatural was actually turned into an Anime Series! If they missed it, this box set will be a real treat – jump back into the world of Supernatural and see it from a whole new perspective with the Anime Series.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Box: Mystery Gift Box Subscription

The gift that keeps on giving – literally. This Supernatural Box: Mystery Box Subscription will gift them exclusive SPN merch 4 times a year! Supernatural will live on when they have this gift to look forward to.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Pop Quiz Trivia Deck

They say they’re a fan but how much do they really know? Test their knowledge and go head to head with other SPN fans with Supernatural Pop Quiz Trivia. A great party game for your next SPN-fandom get-together.

Buy it NowFrom amazon

Hunter Comic Series Shower Curtain

Who wants a boring shower curtain when they could have one that shows off their fandom? This Hunter Comic Series Shower Curtain will be the focal piece in their bathroom.

Buy it Nowfrom amazon

Supernatural Anti-Possession Symbol Phone Case

We know all too well from Supernatural that phones, cars, it can all be possessed. Protect yourself and your tech with this Supernatural Anti-Possession Symbol Phone Case.

Buy it Nowfrom wb shop

Dean Winchester Mug Shot T-Shirt

The quintessential Dean picture can be with you forever with this Dean Winchester Mug Shot T-Shirt. Show your love of Dean with this funny graphic tee.

Buy it Nowfrom wb shop

Sam Winchester Mug Shot T-Shirt

More of a Sam fan? The Sam Winchester Mug Shot T-Shirt will be your new favorite graphic tee!

Buy it Nowfrom wb shop

Supernatural Tote Bag

Whether you’re lugging around your hunting gear, or bringing books from the library back to the bunker to do research this Supernatural Tote Bag will come in handy. Show your love of Supernatural with a Tote Bag that would definitely be something Becky would sell!

Buy it Nowfrom redbubble

Peace Out, Bitches!

While the show may be over, with a fandom as dedicated as this one – Supernatural really isn’t going anywhere. So if you want to help keep Supernatural alive for the SPN fan in your life, the gifts on this list will be sure to impress!

Sign Up For E-Mail Updates!

(Do people still read e-mails?)

About the Author

Stacey

Stacey is a content writer and blogger, who was raised on all things Marvel and Sci-Fi. She's a lover of comics, coffee and cute animals and does a killer Captain Marvel cosplay (if she does say so herself).

Leave a Comment